G・v・ベロウとO・ブルンナーの中世国家論の比較について

URI http://harp.lib.hiroshima-u.ac.jp/hbg/metadata/11269
ファイル
タイトル
G・v・ベロウとO・ブルンナーの中世国家論の比較について
別タイトル
The Comparison of the Views of the Staatliche in the Middle Ages with those of G. v. Below and 0.Brunner
著者
氏名 坂田 正二
ヨミ サカタ セイジ
別名
内容記述

It is an essential goal of the study of medieval history to decide whether the Staatliche is universal in itself, or it is something historical that especially developed in Modern Ages; for the study of medieval study, if the Staatliche is universal, we should regard the social order as the one produced by the Staatliche. If the Staatliche is not universal, however, we cannot help noticing the proper principle of the social order in Middle Ages different from the one in Modern Ages. Now, I'll introduce you two scholars G. v. Below (1858~1927) and O. Brunner (1898~ ), who have opposite opinions in their books: Der deutsche Staat des Mittelalters, 2. Aufl., 1927, Leipzig and Land und Herrschaft, Grundfragen der territorialen Verfassungsgeschichte S?dostdeutschlands im Mittelalter, 2. Aufl., 1943, Wien, and I have tried to compare their opinions in this paper. G. v. Below asserts that the Staatliche is the universal affair and the Staatliche in the Middle Ages is succeeded by the Modern Ages. On the other hand, O. Brunner maintains that in the Middle Ages there was the proper principle of the social construction, apart from the modern state. As this paper tells you, I compared both scholars' conceptions as that of Gerichtsbarkeit, Fehde, Friede and that of Volk. I think that these different conceptions are the opposite points of not only the two scholars, but the two currents of german schools.

掲載雑誌名
広島文化女子短期大学紀要
9
開始ページ
1
終了ページ
9
出版年月日
1976-07-20
出版者
広島文化女子短期大学
ISSN
09137068
NCID
AN00213869
本文言語
日本語
資料タイプ
紀要論文
著者版フラグ
出版社版
旧URI
区分
hbg